A teacher in Queens shelters as students storm the halls because she went to a pro-Israel rally. A father in Brooklyn shields his son from a Palestinian-hating coffee thrower. Three Jewish men are beaten in an anti-Semitic spurt of violence. A man spews anti-Islamic remarks at a halal food cart vendor. A surge in hate crimes has plagued New York City since the brutal terror attacks of Oct. 7 sparked a war between Israel and Hamas, the volume more than doubling in October as deep political divisions erupted onto college campuses and city streets. But, for many, the divide runs...